Insights

Pitching under pressure: you do it more often than you think

Say the word “pitch” and most people picture a founder on Dragons’ Den, or a salesperson with a slide deck. So they decide it isn’t their problem. They don’t sell anything.

Then on Tuesday they walk into a meeting to ask for budget, and their mind goes blank the moment the director leans back and says, “Why now?”

That was a pitch. Most of us make several a week without ever calling them that.

What a pitch actually is

Here is the definition we use with clients: a pitch is any moment you need someone who could say no to say yes.

It doesn’t need a deck or a stage. It needs three things: a person with the power to decide, something you want them to decide, and a real chance they won’t.

By that definition you pitch far more often than you think. A few of the rooms we prepare people for:

  • Taking an idea to senior stakeholders, whether that’s a new process, a hire or a change of direction
  • Getting your own team behind a plan in a meeting, especially one they didn’t ask for
  • Asking for investment, from outside investors or from your own leadership for internal funding
  • Winning a new client, or keeping one who is wavering
  • A job interview, where the thing being pitched is you
  • Making the case for your own promotion or pay rise

The setting changes. The job doesn’t. In every one of these rooms you are asking someone to back you, and they are deciding whether they will.

Giving pitching a new meaning

A lot of people tense up at the word because it sounds like persuasion, or worse, like being salesy. I’d rather you thought about it differently.

A good pitch makes the decision easy for the other person. That’s all.

It moves the focus off you (“how am I coming across?”) and on to them (“what do they need to hear to say yes?”). The director in that budget meeting doesn’t need your full research history. She needs to know what you want, why it matters to her area, and what happens if she says no. Give her that in the first minute and you’ve done most of the work.

When you see it this way, pitching stops being a performance and becomes a service to the person deciding.

How pressure gets in the way

Almost everyone knows their material. What goes wrong is what happens to them when the stakes rise.

In our sessions we see the same patterns again and again. People overexplain, because silence feels dangerous. They bury the ask at the end, or skip it altogether. They pile on caveats to protect themselves from being wrong. And the first time someone interrupts with a hard question, they lose their thread and start defending instead of answering.

None of this is a confidence problem in the way people assume. It’s a preparation problem. Most of us prepare alone, in our heads or on a laptop, with nobody pushing back. Then the first time anyone challenges the idea is in the room that matters. Of course it wobbles.

Start with the outcome you’re after

Before you think about slides or wording, answer one question: what do I want this person to do when I stop talking?

Approve the budget. Agree to a second meeting. Offer you the role. Put their name to the plan. Write it down in one sentence. If you can’t, the people listening won’t be able to work it out either.

Then build everything around that sentence. A simple structure we teach is PREP: make your point, give your reason, back it with one example, then repeat the point. It forces you to lead with the answer, which is exactly what senior people want and exactly what pressure makes us forget.

A short checklist for your next pitch

  1. Write the outcome you want in one sentence.
  2. Open with that outcome, not with the background.
  3. Pick one example or number that proves your case. Just one.
  4. List the three questions you’d least like to be asked, and answer them out loud.
  5. Rehearse with someone who will interrupt you, not someone who will nod.

That last step is the one people skip, and it’s the one that changes the result. You can’t learn to stay clear under pressure without some pressure to practise in.

Practise it before it counts

That’s what our Saturday masterclass in Mayfair is for. You bring a real pitch, whether it’s an idea for your leadership team, a client meeting or an interview coming up. You practise it live, under realistic pressure, and get expert feedback on what to change. You leave with a structure you can use on Monday.

Share this article

Want help with a moment that matters?

Or come to the next Saturday masterclass

What kind of speaker are you?

Take the free 3-minute EDGE profile. See how your style compares with what the people you speak to most need from you, and get your results straight away.